The Monkees vs Jethro Tull

I think you are selling both bands short here....

 

The Monkees versus Jethro Tull? I don't get it. Why not Ian Flemming versus James Joyce? I dont see any connection between these artists.


edit: oh, I see your two favorite bands. Well, Tull, I guess. Both are bands I have to be in the mood for.

 

Take it, they are yours.

 

I agree with the point made above about who plays what. My appreciation of a band hinges on based on the quality of the recordings and performances produced by that entity, not on whether the people doing the writing and playing are the same ones as those who get their picture on the album cover,

 

Look at the animals...only one Tiger Toon.

 

Gets my vote.

Darryl

 

Herman's Hermits or Anal C**t?

 

The Grammy goes to . . .


METALLICA!

 

What are your plans for the losing band?

 

+1 (Jethro Tull)

 

I'm considering a Sinatra vs. Megadeth poll.

 

Who toured longer?
Who has more albums?
Who has had more concerts?
Who has been around longer?
Who didn't need a tv show?
Who really looks like a band?
Who has an album put out on DCC?
Who didn't have screaming little kids watch and listen to them?

 

Who friggin' cares?

 

Not one bit of criteria I ever consider when judging the merits of a bands music.

 

I agree.

The Monkees are one of the of the greatest bands of all time. Although Jethro Tull is not one of my faves they are far more than "long boring flute solos".

 

So then you picked Tull, very smart.

 

Jethro Tull by a landslide.

 

Oh God, one of the greatest of all time. You should be band just for that statement.

 

87 to 82 is a landslide?

You must be a politician.

 

How did you come to that conclusion?

I love Tull. But I chose The Monkees. I've just always been a Monkees freak! I never thought I'd have to pick between the two though. Of course this is all meaningless fun, yes?

 

Are you serious about this?

 

I'm just play'n like most others. Relax.