PDA

View Full Version : DVD Audio Questions


Ted Bell
08-29-2003, 07:22 AM
I've been seeing some interesting titles coming out on DVD-A, reading a few things here, and I have a few questions for those in the know:

1. Does the player need to be hooked up to a TV to negotiate menus, etc?

2. Are the two channel mixes superior to redbook?

I already have an SACD player, not interested in surround at all and not interested if you need to hook up to a TV. With this in mind, is it worth buying a player?

quadjoe
08-29-2003, 08:01 AM
Ted:

The DVD-A format does sample at a higher rate and provide greater resolution than CD: CD sample rate is 16 bit/44.1khz, whereas the DVD-A sample rate is 24 bit/96khz. DVD-A can be sampled at the same rate as CD to give really long playing time. The highest resolution that DVD-A is capable of is 176.4khz or 192khz which are reserved for stereo or mono only . To read more in detail about DVD-A I suggest http://www.sonic.com/pdf/wp_dvd_audio.pdf which may tell you more about it than you wish to know. As for whether or not you have to use a TV to operate the player, it all depends on the player, and you should search carefully (there are supposedly DVD-Audio only players, but you probably won't find them at BB or CC). I can operate my player without the TV (Panasonic RP-82), but it isn't as convenient: the buttons toggle through the settings. Now, the biggie: most DVD-A discs, if not all, contain a Dolby Digital (usually 5.1, but sometimes it's just stereo) track at standard resolution, some contain high-res stereo mixes only along with the DD track, while yet others add a high-res mix in surround as well, so you should look at each disc to see what it contains. As far as sound goes: I'm very happy (I confess I like surround, and I always have) with the discs I have. I have listened to the high-res stereo mixes and they are stunning, in particular the one that amazes my friends is the Grateful Dead's "American Beauty" there is a clarity of sound that is simply breathtaking, and if you ever decide to listen in MC you'll hear the mix as Mickey Hart heard the Dead when they played on stage (he's the drummer, and he had the surround mix done from his vantage point--very clever). I think DVD-A is worthwhile even if you never listen in surround, IMHO. Good Luck with your choice. :)

OOPS!! DON'T click the link, It doesn't seem to work, (maybe their server went down, I can't even access the web site at this time (10:10am CDT)). I'll try to find out and re-post the link.

quadjoe

Taurus
08-29-2003, 07:12 PM
Ted: If you only listen to the stereo tracks, then you probably won't need the on-screen menus. On my Pioneer DV-656A (http://pioneerelectronics.com/pe/product/detail/0,,2076_4139_35102,00.html) when I choose the 2.0 analog output mode in the "Initial Settings" menu, it automatically plays the dvd-audio's stereo tracks (I guess until the player was left unplugged for awhile?). No special button/icon pushes required.

2) On my mid-fi system, the dvd-audio does sound better than the CD version, but nothing that requires a change of underwear.:) Bass is unchanged; mids are fuller and have "deeper" imaging (hard to describe); but highs are the most improved--no graininess anymore & better detail.

[T]

quadjoe
08-29-2003, 08:58 PM
:) Ok, the link is working now. Their server must have been down.