Who question for Steve Hoffman or Luke

[Grant]

I was browsing in a used record store and found a good copy of the Who's LP "Who's Missing". I noticed Steve compiled and remastered it.

What I want to know is, before I attempt to master this to CD-R, has this already been issued on CD? Is the CD a Hoffman master?

[lukpac]

Originally posted by Grant T.:
I was browsing in a used record store and found a good copy of the Who's LP "Who's Missing". I noticed Steve compiled and remastered it.

What I want to know is, before I attempt to master this to CD-R, has this already been issued on CD? Is the CD a Hoffman master?

It's on CD, mastered by Steve, and in print (in Canada). Check out hmv.com. Cheap too.

On the other hand, while the LP of Two's Missing was mastered by Steve, the CD was not, and is noticeably thinner sounding, especially on the stereo Talmy tracks. That CD is *not* in print these days.

[Grant]

Originally posted by Luke Pacholski:


It's on CD, mastered by Steve, and in print (in Canada). Check out hmv.com. Cheap too.

On the other hand, while the LP of Two's Missing was mastered by Steve, the CD was not, and is noticeably thinner sounding, especially on the stereo Talmy tracks. That CD is *not* in print these days.

That sounds contradictory. Do you mean it's been remastered domestically? Will you clarify your above statement?

[lukpac]

Originally posted by Grant T.:
That sounds contradictory. Do you mean it's been remastered domestically? Will you clarify your above statement?

The Who's Missing CD available in Canada today (and often available as an import) uses the mastering Steve did back in 1985 or whatever it was. The master has never been changed for the CD, to my knowledge.

[Kevin Korom]

Luke, I think you're saying Who's Missing when you mean Who's Next? I think that's where the confusion's coming from...

[lukpac]

Originally posted by Kevin Korom:
Luke, I think you're saying Who's Missing when you mean Who's Next? I think that's where the confusion's coming from...

No, I don't. I mean Who's Missing. The CD is available in Canada, just like Who's Next. And Meaty Beaty Big And Bouncy.
How about those Canadians?!

[Craig]

Go back and read Luke's original reply. He was addressing WHO's Missing and TWO's Missing. I was confused a bit at first also until I reread his post.

-Craig

[czeskleba]

Originally posted by Grant T.:
That sounds contradictory. Do you mean it's been remastered domestically? Will you clarify your above statement?

He's talking about TWO different albums, "Who's Missing" and its sequel, "Two's Missing."

Who's Missing, both vinyl and CD versions, were mastered by Steve, and the CD is still in print in Canada.

Two's Missing, vinyl version was mastered by Steve but the CD version was NOT. And, it's not in print anywhere. The CD version tends to go for ridiculous prices on ebay, but apparently sounds worse than the easier-to-find LP version.

[Grant]

Well, the LP has many clicks but still sounds quite good, and it's good music! I'll do my own transfer.